I understand the allure to go bigger and better. I think it’s natural to want that and when the opportunity presents itself, to go for it. Especially for athletes that through HS made “it” happen on the field. That success breeds the self confidence to take a chance on one’s self. But looking at a position group that is 6-8 guys deep, sometimes even more, someone ain’t gonna cut the mustard and will get left out.
The way college fb is arranged these days, I think it would be advantageous to stay a big fish in a small pond, especially if the goal is playing time and an opportunity at the next level, but that’s probably difficult for an 18-21 year old to rationalize.